Councilman Echos Mayor's Budget Concerns
Councilman Michael Vernotico has also issued a statement about his feelings concerning the budget impacts on safety in Summit.
Councilman Michael Vernotico released the following statement in agreement with Mayor Jordan Glatt's previous statement about his concerns regarding budget cuts and their impacts on public safety in Summit:
I applaud Mayor Glatt's Op Ed piece. What the Finance Committee, specifically Messers Madden, Getzendanner and Bomgaars has done is create a budget that will increase our property taxes while making our Community less safe. It is a budget that will build in a process whereby we will make the community less and less safe each ensuing year. Specifically, their budget does the following:
1. It has no money to replace the 2 current vacancies in the Police Department. Police Officer head count will be reduced from the current number of 48 to 46.
2. It changes the replacement schedule for police vehicles from 3 years to 6 years, which simply is unmanageable.
3. It reduces the overtime budget from last year by $30,000 for each department. We currently are over last year's overtime budgets and we exceeded last year's budget. We always do. It is not rational to assume you can eliminate police officers and reduce overtime. The reason the PD and FD have high OT numbers is because they have reduced staffing in the past and are now at minimal levels.
4. The reduced OT numbers will mean that the FD will not be able to fight fires in excess of 51 shifts until personnel are recalled. This means we in effect are becoming a quasi -Volunteer FD.
5. The Council rejected a proposal from the PBA that involved givebacks of approximately $45,000 a year over the next 3 years in return for saving these two positions.
The math doesn't work. The increase OT couple with the PBA givebacks exceeds the salary of two new police officers. This vote will actually cost the taxpayers of Summit more money and make it less safe at a critical time. The Morris Avenue bridge will be replaced next year and it will likely take a year. There simply will not be police personnel available for the extra duty that might be required. If I lived on Woodland, Passiac, Summit Avenues or Kent Place Boulevard, I would be very concerned.
There is an even more frightening aspect of Council's actions. We will not be able to meet the reduced OT budgets. This means that we will have to reallocate money in November, the only time we are permitted to do so. Since this is a bare bones budget and most of it will have been expended by then, our only realistic option is to "borrow" against next year's budget. So, you will be reducing next year's OT budget further despite the fact you missed last year's. This is likely to result in further cuts to Police and Fire next year when the cycle will repeat itself. This commonly is referred to as a "death spiral." Once you start, you cannot get out and if we go from a 4.0% Cap to a 2.5% Cap, it will further aggravate an already unworkable situation. We will be on a path of reducing Fire and Police and making our City less and less safe despite ever new and challenging demands. This is not fear mongering. It is reality.
If you are as concerned as I and the Mayor are, I suggest you make those concerns known before the damage is done. Phone, email, write. or better yet, attend the June 1 Council Meeting and be heard.
Michael J. Vernotico
Joseph Wurtzbacher
11:09 am on Friday, May 28, 2010
Thank You Mayor Glatt, Councilman Murphy & Councilman Vernotico for supporting our Police and Fire Depts. No budget, City, County, State or Federal should be balanced on the backs of Public Safety. For as long as I have been a proud employee of the Fire Dept. and the City of Summit, we have always been conservative in our spending. No Summit Fire Chief, all who worked responsibly with City Administrators, excessively spent or wasted taxpayer money in the Fire Dept. The reality is it does take money to buy, maintain equipment and train Firefighters to respond with the equipment needed to get the job done and to do it safely. The reality is takes Firefighters to put out fires, minimize hazards at auto accidents, pump basements, assist residents with questions, odors, investigations, First Responder (medical) calls, building inspections or anything else the Citizens call us for. Our FMBA worked with the City to help support the budget, we didn't have our hand out, we gave back. This whole economic mess was caused by irresponsible Politicians and irresponsible financial decisions made by them- NOT Firemen or Policemen. Summit is and hopefully will continue to be a great place to live, I will not and hope others will not support Politicians who don't support us, expect no support from me on Primary Day Tues. June 8th. It's time for angry taxpayers, like myself, to go after the real spending waste in Government that's in County, State & Federal budgets.
Joseph Wurtzbacher
Guy Haselmann
12:15 pm on Saturday, May 29, 2010
I praise Mayor Glatt and Councilman Vernotico for their thoughtful and detailed comments. They have valid concerns. We have all been impacted and bothered by our increasing property taxes. However, I believe strongly that the problem is not solved by cutting police and fire personnel: departments which have been shrinking for years while Summit has been growing. Comparisons to similar towns show Summit's P&F departments operating with fewer staff per capaita. Summit should actually require greater capabilities for numerous reasons:
(police) situated between major highways - an easy getaway for crooks; (fire) Overlook Hospital, Merck and Celgene require sophisticated fire capabilities. Presently both departments are already operating at sub-optimal levels; slowing response times and increasing overtime costs. Quick response times typically maximizes the probability of our safety. Councilman Vernotico outlines clear arguments and shows how the numbers simply do not add up. No one needs to be a math wiz to understand that if you cut personnel than overtime increases and is thus MORE costly. To assume both a cut in staff AND a decrease in overtime is disingenuous and absurd. The police and fire unions have voluntarily offered to break their contracts. They have not been given enough credit for such sacrifice. Mr. Hurley focused his attack on Mr. Vernotico's character, probably because he did not have a counter-argument to Mr. Vernotico's well thought out points.